• Contact us
  • About us
  • Digital edition
  • Online archive
Wednesday, April 16, 2025
Cumberland and Westmorland Herald
  • News
    Further measures to close the tax compliance gap

    Further measures to close the tax compliance gap

    Body found after major search for Penrith man

    Body found after major search for Penrith man

    Eden village school leaders upbeat after Ofsted inspection

    Eden village school leaders upbeat after Ofsted inspection

    £300,000 Ullswater Steamers upgrade project sunk

    £300,000 Ullswater Steamers upgrade project sunk

    Penrith furniture store to close after 80 years

    Penrith furniture store to close after 80 years

    Penrith teacher banned over relationship with student

    Penrith teacher banned over relationship with student

    Stallion sculpture plans for Appleby thrown out

    Stallion sculpture plans for Appleby thrown out

    Fighting ‘the family farm tax’ with good financial planning

    Fighting ‘the family farm tax’ with good financial planning

    Popular Penrith pub reopens

    Popular Penrith pub reopens

  • Sport
    Kirkby Stephen Hockey Club win league title

    Kirkby Stephen Hockey Club win league title

    Dedicated Eden football volunteer wins major award

    Dedicated Eden football volunteer wins major award

    10-year-old footballer Casper Ostrowski snapped up by Morecambe

    10-year-old footballer Casper Ostrowski snapped up by Morecambe

    Kirkby Stephen U18s win bronze at national hockey championships

    Kirkby Stephen U18s win bronze at national hockey championships

    Penrith swimmer inducted into Cumbria hall of fame

    Penrith swimmer inducted into Cumbria hall of fame

    Louie Johnson makes first Premiership start for Saracens

    Louie Johnson makes first Premiership start for Saracens

    Eden man wins UK’s toughest endurance race

    Eden man wins UK’s toughest endurance race

    Young Eden shooting star returns to world stage

    Young Eden shooting star returns to world stage

    160 take part in Melmerby Scar Christmas Challenge

    160 take part in Melmerby Scar Christmas Challenge

  • Obituaries
  • Nostalgia
  • Online archive
  • Buy Photos
  • Buy your paper
  • North Lakes Living
No Result
View All Result
Cumberland and Westmorland Herald
  • News
    Further measures to close the tax compliance gap

    Further measures to close the tax compliance gap

    Body found after major search for Penrith man

    Body found after major search for Penrith man

    Eden village school leaders upbeat after Ofsted inspection

    Eden village school leaders upbeat after Ofsted inspection

    £300,000 Ullswater Steamers upgrade project sunk

    £300,000 Ullswater Steamers upgrade project sunk

    Penrith furniture store to close after 80 years

    Penrith furniture store to close after 80 years

    Penrith teacher banned over relationship with student

    Penrith teacher banned over relationship with student

    Stallion sculpture plans for Appleby thrown out

    Stallion sculpture plans for Appleby thrown out

    Fighting ‘the family farm tax’ with good financial planning

    Fighting ‘the family farm tax’ with good financial planning

    Popular Penrith pub reopens

    Popular Penrith pub reopens

  • Sport
    Kirkby Stephen Hockey Club win league title

    Kirkby Stephen Hockey Club win league title

    Dedicated Eden football volunteer wins major award

    Dedicated Eden football volunteer wins major award

    10-year-old footballer Casper Ostrowski snapped up by Morecambe

    10-year-old footballer Casper Ostrowski snapped up by Morecambe

    Kirkby Stephen U18s win bronze at national hockey championships

    Kirkby Stephen U18s win bronze at national hockey championships

    Penrith swimmer inducted into Cumbria hall of fame

    Penrith swimmer inducted into Cumbria hall of fame

    Louie Johnson makes first Premiership start for Saracens

    Louie Johnson makes first Premiership start for Saracens

    Eden man wins UK’s toughest endurance race

    Eden man wins UK’s toughest endurance race

    Young Eden shooting star returns to world stage

    Young Eden shooting star returns to world stage

    160 take part in Melmerby Scar Christmas Challenge

    160 take part in Melmerby Scar Christmas Challenge

  • Obituaries
  • Nostalgia
  • Online archive
  • Buy Photos
  • Buy your paper
  • North Lakes Living
No Result
View All Result
Cumberland and Westmorland Herald
No Result
View All Result
Home Latest

£450,000 bill to unblock Eden railway bridge

by CWH
21 June 2022
in Latest, News
A A
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Great Musgrave Bridge

More than 1,600 tonnes of aggregate and concrete used to fill in an old railway bridge in Eden must be removed at a cost of £450,000

National Highways buried a stone arch bridge at Great Musgrave last year, blocking the route.

The work caused outrage, as for 27 years, Eden Valley and Stainmore railways have been working towards the relaying of five miles of track between Warcop and Kirkby Stephen.

An engineer employed by the state-owned roads company told Eden District Council that infilling was needed “to prevent the failure of the bridge and avert a collapse”.

However, since 2017, inspections had found the structure to be in fair condition, with only a handful of minor defects. Repointing open mortar joints — costing around £20,000 — would have enabled the structure to carry 40-tonne vehicles,

The work was carried out during May and June last year under powers intended for emergency situations presenting a threat of death or injury, with the material allowed to remain in situ for no longer than 12 months.

The council has insisted that planning permission must be obtained for retention beyond this period. Eden council’s planning committee considered the application this week.

Picture: The HRE Group

Historical Railways Estate, acting on behalf of the Department for Transport, was refused retrospective planning permission following a unanimous vote.

The work to infill the bridge with concrete, initially carried out as emergency work to safeguard the structure, will cost an estimated £450,000 to remove, but if the application had been approved, the meeting was told that the £450,000 budget would instead have been ring-fenced to be used on the “improvement and maintenance of railway assets in the Eden Valley”.

Tim Wells, chairman of Musgrave Parish Council, said while it would be good to see the former railway line used again, their thinking was not pie in the sky, and the most important thing was the preservation of Musgrave Bridge.

“We now have this massive lot of concrete around this soft sandstone bridge, so water will end up in the stone, so long term this bridge is going to be damaged more than ever. “It’s not just bridges — we are losing our history,” said Mr Wells.

He said councillors on the planning committee had a moral obligation to think about what was being left for generations to come.

“If we keep using cement on these bridges and houses we will be losing an awful lot of history that future children will never see,” he added.

National Highways’ head of the historical railways estate programme, Hélène Rossiter, said: “Public safety is our absolute priority and despite concerns being raised by others about the need for the works, the process to assess the structure was robust.”

Great Musgrave Bridge

She said the work was undertaken by experienced and highly qualified engineers and followed a detailed inspection which had been carried out by Cumbria County Council in 1998 which confirmed the bridge was weak and required weight restrictions or strengthening.

The council did not undertake this work, and further inspections and visual checks confirmed that the bridge was deteriorating and “significant works” were required.

Following advice from Eden council in April 2020, that the works constituted permitted development, the infill project started in May, 2021, and was completed the following month.

“We have offered to remove the infill if and when a viable plan for the reopening of the former railway is proposed,” said Ms Rossister. She added that the infill scheme was a “small and discreet change” and the work was fully reversible.

“We believe the delivered works will actually protect the bridge for potential future use and that the infill is able to be removed without damage,” said Ms Rossiter.

Following a unanimous vote to refuse the retrospective planning permission, committee chairman William Patterson began to seek approval for an enforcement order to be made, before being told that would have to wait as it was not an item listed on the agenda.

After the meeting, Ms Rossiter, said: “We respect Eden District Council’s decision regarding our planning application to retain the works at Great Musgrave, and will not be appealing.

“We have listened to the feedback on this issue and earlier this year amended our processes to ensure full planning permission is sought before carrying out work like this in the future.

“Our new process of managing the estate, which has full stakeholder engagement, means we will review each structure against a range of criteria, not only for repurposing but also for heritage or ecological value.

“We will also no longer consider the infilling of any structures as part of our future plans, unless there is absolutely no alternative.”

Related Posts

Further measures to close the tax compliance gap
Expert advice

Further measures to close the tax compliance gap

15 April 2025
Body found after major search for Penrith man
Latest

Body found after major search for Penrith man

15 April 2025
Eden village school leaders upbeat after Ofsted inspection
News

Eden village school leaders upbeat after Ofsted inspection

14 April 2025
£300,000 Ullswater Steamers upgrade project sunk
News

£300,000 Ullswater Steamers upgrade project sunk

11 April 2025
Penrith furniture store to close after 80 years
Latest

Penrith furniture store to close after 80 years

11 April 2025
Penrith teacher banned over relationship with student
Latest

Penrith teacher banned over relationship with student

11 April 2025
No Result
View All Result

Stay connected

Facebook Twitter Instagram

Most popular

Further measures to close the tax compliance gap

Further measures to close the tax compliance gap

15 April 2025
£300,000 Ullswater Steamers upgrade project sunk

£300,000 Ullswater Steamers upgrade project sunk

11 April 2025
Body found after major search for Penrith man

Body found after major search for Penrith man

15 April 2025
Penrith furniture store to close after 80 years

Penrith furniture store to close after 80 years

11 April 2025
Penrith teacher banned over relationship with student

Penrith teacher banned over relationship with student

11 April 2025
Memory lane – July 1995

Memory lane – July 1995

11 April 2025
Cumberland and Westmorland Herald Logo

33 Middlegate
Penrith
Cumbria
CA11 7SY

Phone: 01768 862313
Email: news@cwherald.com

Registered in England as Barrnon Media Limited. No: 12475190
VAT registration number: 343486488

Explore

  • News
  • Sport
  • Farming
  • Property
  • Obituaries
  • Nostalgia
  • Your view

Useful links

  • Contact us
  • Photosales
  • Online archive
  • Buy your paper
  • Digital edition
  • North Lakes Living
  • Advertise
  • About us

Follow us on

© Barrnon Media Limited 2020

Terms & Conditions / Privacy Policy / Cookie Policy

This website and its associated newspaper are members of the Independent Press Standards Organisation
IPSO Logo
Review Your Cart
0
Discount
Add Coupon Code
Subtotal
Total Installment Payments
Bundle Discount
Checkout

 
0
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Obituaries
  • Nostalgia
  • Online archive
  • more
    • North Lakes Living
    • Buy Photos
    • Buy your paper
    • About us
    • Contact us

© 2020 Cumberland & Westmorland Herald