• Contact us
  • About us
  • Digital edition
  • Online archive
Sunday, June 22, 2025
Cumberland and Westmorland Herald
  • News
    Is outsourcing a strategic opportunity amid rising employment costs?

    Is outsourcing a strategic opportunity amid rising employment costs?

    Farms focus on cashflow following SFI scheme closure

    Farms focus on cashflow following SFI scheme closure

    MP asks for Government help over plans to replace M6 bridges

    MP asks for Government help over plans to replace M6 bridges

    Resurfacing work to start in Shap – road to be closed for 21 days

    Resurfacing work to start in Shap – road to be closed for 21 days

    Arrests after drugs raid in Penrith

    Arrests after drugs raid in Penrith

    New Kirkby Stephen shop blends retail with purpose

    New Kirkby Stephen shop blends retail with purpose

    New vicar appointed for churches

    New vicar appointed for churches

    Award for Eden writer

    Award for Eden writer

    Penrith man admits possessing cannabis twice with intent to supply

    Penrith man admits possessing cannabis twice with intent to supply

  • Sport
    Medal success for Upper Eden tug-of-war team

    Medal success for Upper Eden tug-of-war team

    Eden man competes in Hyrox World Games

    Eden man competes in Hyrox World Games

    Double national triumph for Stuart Robinson

    Double national triumph for Stuart Robinson

    Patterdale’s Eden Eagles make history

    Patterdale’s Eden Eagles make history

    Penrith teen crowned British vault champion

    Penrith teen crowned British vault champion

    Penrith gymnasts represent North of England in finals

    Penrith gymnasts represent North of England in finals

    New boss revealed for Penrith AFC

    New boss revealed for Penrith AFC

    Penrith Panthers celebrate winning season

    Penrith Panthers celebrate winning season

    Darren Edmondson leaves Penrith AFC

    Darren Edmondson leaves Penrith AFC

  • Obituaries
  • Nostalgia
  • Online archive
  • Buy Photos
  • Buy your paper
  • North Lakes Living
No Result
View All Result
Cumberland and Westmorland Herald
  • News
    Is outsourcing a strategic opportunity amid rising employment costs?

    Is outsourcing a strategic opportunity amid rising employment costs?

    Farms focus on cashflow following SFI scheme closure

    Farms focus on cashflow following SFI scheme closure

    MP asks for Government help over plans to replace M6 bridges

    MP asks for Government help over plans to replace M6 bridges

    Resurfacing work to start in Shap – road to be closed for 21 days

    Resurfacing work to start in Shap – road to be closed for 21 days

    Arrests after drugs raid in Penrith

    Arrests after drugs raid in Penrith

    New Kirkby Stephen shop blends retail with purpose

    New Kirkby Stephen shop blends retail with purpose

    New vicar appointed for churches

    New vicar appointed for churches

    Award for Eden writer

    Award for Eden writer

    Penrith man admits possessing cannabis twice with intent to supply

    Penrith man admits possessing cannabis twice with intent to supply

  • Sport
    Medal success for Upper Eden tug-of-war team

    Medal success for Upper Eden tug-of-war team

    Eden man competes in Hyrox World Games

    Eden man competes in Hyrox World Games

    Double national triumph for Stuart Robinson

    Double national triumph for Stuart Robinson

    Patterdale’s Eden Eagles make history

    Patterdale’s Eden Eagles make history

    Penrith teen crowned British vault champion

    Penrith teen crowned British vault champion

    Penrith gymnasts represent North of England in finals

    Penrith gymnasts represent North of England in finals

    New boss revealed for Penrith AFC

    New boss revealed for Penrith AFC

    Penrith Panthers celebrate winning season

    Penrith Panthers celebrate winning season

    Darren Edmondson leaves Penrith AFC

    Darren Edmondson leaves Penrith AFC

  • Obituaries
  • Nostalgia
  • Online archive
  • Buy Photos
  • Buy your paper
  • North Lakes Living
No Result
View All Result
Cumberland and Westmorland Herald
No Result
View All Result
Home Latest

Cumbria County Council legal challenge continues: Everything you need to know

by CWH
24 September 2021
in Latest, News
A A
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Cumbria County Council is to press ahead with its legal challenge against the government regarding its plans for local government reform despite a vote by councillors which said that such a move would be a “waste of time and money”.
Cumbria House. Picture: Google Streetview

Cumbria County Council is to press ahead with its legal challenge against the government regarding its plans for local government reform despite a vote by councillors which said that such a move would be a “waste of time and money”.

The authority’s cabinet met last night to discuss the Housing, Communities and Local Government Secretary Robert Jenrick’s response to a pre-action protocol letter sent on August 9.

A pre-action protocol letter sets out the position of the claimant, which in this case is Cumbria County Council, prior to any court proceedings.

Govt response to pre-action letter.pdf (cumbria.gov.uk)

Last night the council’s cabinet voted in favour of continuing the legal challenge against the Government’s decision.

How did we get here?

Mr Jenrick announced his decision on July 21, subject to Parliamentary approval, to back two unitary authorities in Cumbria on an east/west split.

He received four proposals from councils in Cumbria and decided on the joint bid submitted by Allerdale and Copeland Borough Councils.

The four proposals were as follows:

  • The two councils – Allerdale and Copeland – jointly submitted a proposal for two unitary councils: West Cumbria comprising the area covered by Allerdale Borough, Carlisle City and Copeland Borough Councils  and East Cumbria comprising the area covered by Barrow Borough, Eden District and South Lakeland District Councils.
  • The two councils – Barrow and South Lakeland  – jointly submitted a proposal for two unitary councils: ‘The Bay’ comprising the area covered by Barrow Borough, South Lakeland District and Lancaster City Councils and North Cumbria comprising the area covered by Allerdale Borough, Carlisle City, Copeland Borough and Eden District Councils.
  • The two councils – Carlisle and Eden  – jointly submitted a proposal for two unitary councils: North Cumbria comprising the area covered by Allerdale Borough,  Carlisle City and Eden District Councils and South Cumbria comprising the area covered by Barrow Borough, Copeland Borough and South Lakeland District Councils.
  • Cumbria County Council submitted a proposal for a single unitary council for the area of Cumbria County.

On August 9 Cumbria County Council issued the pre-action protocol letter calling for a judicial review of the decision to back the chosen proposal over its idea of a single unitary authority covering the whole of the county.

The letter requested that the Secretary of State responded by August 23, but an extension was granted on request of the Government, with the response received on September 6.

Why did councillors vote to halt the legal challenge?

A special meeting of Cumbria County Council was called at short notice on August 25 to discuss the legal review.

Councillors resolved that launching a legal challenge against the plans for local government reform in Cumbria would be “a waste of public money and time and that the council should instead focus on serving local residents by working constructively with all partners to ensure a smooth transition to the new unitary authorities.”

However, as the decision to proceed with the judicial review is an executive decision, the vote was not binding.

Why is Cumbria County Council calling for a judicial review?

Cumbria County Council says the purpose of the judicial is “not to examine the decision itself” but to challenge the “process by which the decision was reached”.

It says there are four main grounds for bringing a claim for judicial review, which were illegality, irrationality, procedural impropriety and legitimate expectation.

Cumbria County Council say the decision on the chosen model of local government reform:

A. Left out of account necessarily material considerations which the Secretary of State’s (SoS) guidance requires to be taken into account;
b. Failed to conscientiously consider the consultation responses of Cumbria County Council (CCC) showing why the chosen Two Unitary Approach did not meet the SoS’s own guidance and would not deliver that which his guidance required;
c. Failed to understand or apply his own guidance in terms of the required scale of the new unitary authorities and provided no reason to depart from that guidance;
d. Failed to recognise that the Two Unitary Approach is predicated around the creation of a mayoral combined authority to ensure coordination on key matters thus adding
a new tier of local government administration, undermining the savings claimed and the need for which was a key reason why a Single Unitary Approach was appropriate here;
e. For no valid reason acted inconsistently with his approach in North Yorkshire where a Single Unitary Approach was adopted – in the case of North Yorkshire factors in
favour of a Single Unitary Approach were relied on but the same factors equally applicable to Cumbria were ignored in the Cumbria decision;
f. Appears could have been motivated by the possible party political advantage that splitting Cumbria in two may secure for his party. If this was a factor in the decision, it would be an abuse of power and unlawful;
g. acted irrationally; and
h. failed to provide adequate reasons addressing the principal controversial issues.

To read more on Cumbria County Council’s concerns, click here.

Related Posts

Is outsourcing a strategic opportunity amid rising employment costs?
Expert advice

Is outsourcing a strategic opportunity amid rising employment costs?

22 June 2025
Farms focus on cashflow following SFI scheme closure
Expert advice

Farms focus on cashflow following SFI scheme closure

21 June 2025
MP asks for Government help over plans to replace M6 bridges
Latest

MP asks for Government help over plans to replace M6 bridges

20 June 2025
Resurfacing work to start in Shap – road to be closed for 21 days
Latest

Resurfacing work to start in Shap – road to be closed for 21 days

20 June 2025
Arrests after drugs raid in Penrith
Latest

Arrests after drugs raid in Penrith

20 June 2025
New Kirkby Stephen shop blends retail with purpose
News

New Kirkby Stephen shop blends retail with purpose

20 June 2025
No Result
View All Result

Stay connected

Facebook Twitter Instagram

Most popular

Arrests after drugs raid in Penrith

Arrests after drugs raid in Penrith

20 June 2025
Is outsourcing a strategic opportunity amid rising employment costs?

Is outsourcing a strategic opportunity amid rising employment costs?

22 June 2025
MP asks for Government help over plans to replace M6 bridges

MP asks for Government help over plans to replace M6 bridges

20 June 2025
Award for Eden writer

Award for Eden writer

20 June 2025
New vicar appointed for churches

New vicar appointed for churches

20 June 2025
Looking back through the archives

Looking back through the archives

20 June 2025
Cumberland and Westmorland Herald Logo

33 Middlegate
Penrith
Cumbria
CA11 7SY

Phone: 01768 862313
Email: news@cwherald.com

Registered in England as Barrnon Media Limited. No: 12475190
VAT registration number: 343486488

Explore

  • News
  • Sport
  • Farming
  • Property
  • Obituaries
  • Nostalgia
  • Your view

Useful links

  • Contact us
  • Photosales
  • Online archive
  • Buy your paper
  • Digital edition
  • North Lakes Living
  • Advertise
  • About us

Follow us on

© Barrnon Media Limited 2025

Terms & Conditions / Privacy Policy / Cookie Policy

This website and its associated newspaper are members of the Independent Press Standards Organisation
Review Your Cart
0
Discount
Add Coupon Code
Subtotal
Total Installment Payments
Bundle Discount
Checkout

 
0
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Obituaries
  • Nostalgia
  • Online archive
  • more
    • North Lakes Living
    • Buy Photos
    • Buy your paper
    • About us
    • Contact us

© 2020 Cumberland & Westmorland Herald